“For People Then and for People Now”: Approaches to Heritage and Shared Authority
Themes:
Heritage Changes the Social OrderCitizenship
What:
Regular session
When:
9:00, Tuesday 7 Jun 2016
(6 hours)
Where:
How:
In exploring the broader question “What does heritage change?” this session presents work that is extending heritage policies and practices beyond elite cultural narratives. Using diverse disciplinary perspectives and drawing from case studies around the world, the presenters explore contexts in which stakeholders’ perspectives and choices have been catalysts for change, democratized knowledge, or exposed gaps in contemporary heritage practices. The case studies reveal complex and often contested paradigms of value that different groups bring to public heritage and memory practices, and at the same time they point to new approaches, strategies and methodologies that have been tools for empowering a more inclusive, shared authority approach to heritage sites and collections. These studies humanize the concept of heritage to assert the agency of diverse stakeholders in creatively and intentionally negotiating the politics of the heritage industry and profession to reframe narratives, alter knowledge production and reconfigure social relations.
The presentations trace the political and phenomenological concerns of diverse stakeholders in a wide range of contexts. For example, presenters explore repatriation claims between tribes and government-owned heritage sites in the US Midwest; contested narratives in the planned National Museum of Romanian Communism and the site of Jilava Penitentiary, a former Communist prison, near Bucharest; Native American art objects in a museum collection reinterpreted by Native artists and elders; the entanglements of nationalist politics and grassroots development of projects for cultural preservation in Kyrgyzstan; divergent and convergent meanings of a family-curated museum in Maine, and the findings of an analysis of stakeholder-defined value of cultural heritage at two contested sites in Indiana.
The goal of the session is to highlight innovative strategies for a shared authority approach to cultural heritage. Such an approach acknowledges the agency of diverse stakeholders in navigating structures of power embedded in the mainstream heritage practices and values the counter narratives they produce both with and without the support of dominant institutions.
The presentations trace the political and phenomenological concerns of diverse stakeholders in a wide range of contexts. For example, presenters explore repatriation claims between tribes and government-owned heritage sites in the US Midwest; contested narratives in the planned National Museum of Romanian Communism and the site of Jilava Penitentiary, a former Communist prison, near Bucharest; Native American art objects in a museum collection reinterpreted by Native artists and elders; the entanglements of nationalist politics and grassroots development of projects for cultural preservation in Kyrgyzstan; divergent and convergent meanings of a family-curated museum in Maine, and the findings of an analysis of stakeholder-defined value of cultural heritage at two contested sites in Indiana.
The goal of the session is to highlight innovative strategies for a shared authority approach to cultural heritage. Such an approach acknowledges the agency of diverse stakeholders in navigating structures of power embedded in the mainstream heritage practices and values the counter narratives they produce both with and without the support of dominant institutions.
Sub Sessions
- 14.30 Sustaining Community-Led Heritage Stewardship: Co-Creating a Community-Sourcing Platform for Heritage Management
- Participant Harald Fredheim (University of York)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: “For People Then and for People Now”: Approaches to Heritage and Shared Authority
- Paper
- 09.30 The Legacy of Communism: Difficult Histories and Contested Narratives in Romania
- Participant Dr Sheila Watson (University of Leicester)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: “For People Then and for People Now”: Approaches to Heritage and Shared Authority
- Paper
- 13.30 Local Conservation and Heritage Communities of World Heritage Site Old Rauma
- Participant PhD Eeva Karhunen (University of Turku, Finland) Participant Laura Puolamäki (Rauma Town) | Participant Riina Haanpää (University of Turku, Finland) |
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: “For People Then and for People Now”: Approaches to Heritage and Shared Authority
- Paper
- 14.00 Heritage and the Creation of Rural Identity in Alberta, Canada
- Participant Dr Lianne McTavish (University of Alberta )
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: “For People Then and for People Now”: Approaches to Heritage and Shared Authority
- Paper
- 11.00 “That’s Not a Term I Really Use": Investigating Stakeholders’ Understanding of Heritage
- Participant Prof. Elizabeth Kryder-Reid (Indiana University (IUPUI))
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: “For People Then and for People Now”: Approaches to Heritage and Shared Authority
- Paper
- 11.30 Toward Participatory Development of Museum Performance Indicators: A Means of Embedding "Shared Authority"? Experiences from Aotearoa, New Zealand
- Participant Dr Jane A. Legget (Auckland War Memorial Museum)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: “For People Then and for People Now”: Approaches to Heritage and Shared Authority
- Paper
- 12.00 Democratizing the Museum: An Interdisciplinary Approach to Understanding the Politics of Participation
- Participant Rachael Coghlan (Australian National University)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: “For People Then and for People Now”: Approaches to Heritage and Shared Authority
- Paper
- 09.10 “Home is the Streets”: Collaborative Cultural Heritage Work with Contemporary Homeless People and its Function as Advocacy
- Participant Rachael Kiddey (Independent Social Research Foundation)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: “For People Then and for People Now”: Approaches to Heritage and Shared Authority
- Paper
- 10.00 Authentic Kyrgyzstan: Top-Down Politics Meet Bottom-Up Heritage
- Participant Anne Pyburn (Indiana University)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: “For People Then and for People Now”: Approaches to Heritage and Shared Authority
- Paper