Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
Themes:
Notions of HeritageHeritage Changes Itself (Geographical and Linguistic Processes of Transformation)TourismActivists and Experts
What:
Regular session
When:
9:00, Tuesday 7 Jun 2016
(8 hours)
Where:
How:
To date, there has been much scholarly discussion and critique about how ideas and policies of "heritage" may be operating globally. There have also been ethnographic studies providing "on the ground" perspectives. In this session, we aim to establish a bridge between local-level empirical study and global heritage discourse. By addressing "heritage" in relation to processes of modernization and globalization in East Asia, we seek to investigate the dynamic communication between global heritage policies and local practices in that region. Rather than assuming that a Euro-centric discourse necessarily operates, we intend to explore the dialectical shifts of heritage discourse between international regimes and national and local presentations. We also wish to examine the tensions and opportunities in the process of interpreting, imagining and practicing heritage in the East Asian context of shifting economic and cultural values.
With these issues in mind, we invite papers looking into the following themes:
•What are the routes and modes of transport by which notions such as heritage, preservation, museum or authenticity—that originally emerged from Europe—travel to East Asian countries such as China, Korea or Japan?
•What concepts and practices do such notions meet when they arrive and how do populations interact with them? How are they professionally translated and interpreted and popularly imagined and practised on the ground?
•Through what kinds of processes and practices is the global heritage system variously put into operation and transformed at national and local levels?
•What roles do international professional groups, including heritage experts and nature conservationists, play in shaping the activities of Asian heritage practitioners and managers—and vice versa?
•How are documents and decisions concerning heritage conservation made at international levels (e.g. World Heritage) transmitted to East Asia and how do local actors variously take up, negotiate, resist or ignore these in whole or part?
• In what ways may local heritage decision-makers enlist national and international agents in order to meet their own economic and political agendas?
•How do international tourists and global tour operators imagine and influence heritage tourism in East Asia, and how do those variously respond?
Instead of focusing on single-site case-studies from diverse national contexts, this session engages with East Asia as an important ground for testing the global dynamics of heritage discourse in relation to the intensified mobility of concepts, objects, media and human beings.
We welcome projects with inter-disciplinary approaches to deepen the insight of the complex picture of the heritage system in the era of cultural and economic globalization. By investigating the proposition that cultures are an attribute of human societies formed by transcultural relationships, our session will collectively strive to cast new light on heritage politics, memory, governance, and the complex and often contradictory association of power and culture.
With these issues in mind, we invite papers looking into the following themes:
•What are the routes and modes of transport by which notions such as heritage, preservation, museum or authenticity—that originally emerged from Europe—travel to East Asian countries such as China, Korea or Japan?
•What concepts and practices do such notions meet when they arrive and how do populations interact with them? How are they professionally translated and interpreted and popularly imagined and practised on the ground?
•Through what kinds of processes and practices is the global heritage system variously put into operation and transformed at national and local levels?
•What roles do international professional groups, including heritage experts and nature conservationists, play in shaping the activities of Asian heritage practitioners and managers—and vice versa?
•How are documents and decisions concerning heritage conservation made at international levels (e.g. World Heritage) transmitted to East Asia and how do local actors variously take up, negotiate, resist or ignore these in whole or part?
• In what ways may local heritage decision-makers enlist national and international agents in order to meet their own economic and political agendas?
•How do international tourists and global tour operators imagine and influence heritage tourism in East Asia, and how do those variously respond?
Instead of focusing on single-site case-studies from diverse national contexts, this session engages with East Asia as an important ground for testing the global dynamics of heritage discourse in relation to the intensified mobility of concepts, objects, media and human beings.
We welcome projects with inter-disciplinary approaches to deepen the insight of the complex picture of the heritage system in the era of cultural and economic globalization. By investigating the proposition that cultures are an attribute of human societies formed by transcultural relationships, our session will collectively strive to cast new light on heritage politics, memory, governance, and the complex and often contradictory association of power and culture.
Moderator
California State University Chico, Department of Anthropology, United States
Assistant Professor
Sub Sessions
- 12.00 A Heritage Let Live by Not Letting Die: Unwritten Policies in a Chinese Folk Art Fair
- Participant Jiabao Wang (National University of Singapore)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 11.30 Everyday Narrative Singing and Intangible Cultural Heritage: The Case of Dongguan muk-jyu-go in China
- Participant Ms Cuiyan Wen
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 16.00 Global Archive, Vying National Identities: Contested Korean Histories and UNESCO's Memory of the World Programme
- Participant Nan Kim (University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 10.00 To Theme a Village: The Race for China’s Intangible Cultural Heritage in Mianzhu, Sichuan
- Participant Dr. April Liu (UBC Museum of Anthropology)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 11.00 Heritage in Bondage: On the (Exc)use of “Intangible Cultural Heritage” in Tibet
- Participant Isabelle Henrion-Dourcy (Université Laval)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 15.30 Heritage Conflicts in East Asia: Japan and the Contested Colonial Past
- Participant Ioan Trifu (Goethe University Frankfurt)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 14.00 Exploring Participatory Museum Principles in China
- Participant dr Riemer Knoop (reinwardt academie / gordion cultureel advies)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 16.30 The Silk Roads or Economic Belt: An Analysis of the Interaction Between China’s World Heritage and its Economic and Political Ambitions
- Participant Jieyi Xie (Australian National University)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 09.00 La Convention sur la sauvegarde du Patrimoine Culturel Immatériel en Extrême-Orient : Effet boomerang au niveau local d’un outil mondial
- Participant Dr Caroline Bodolec (CNRS France) | Participant Dr Katiana Le Mentec (CNRS (France))
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 09.30 Conceptualizing Living Heritage in China: The Contested Chinese ICH Discourse
- Participant Dr Yujie Zhu Participant Christina Maags (Goethe University Frankfurt) |
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 13.30 Adopting and Adapting the New Museology Discourse: Ecomuseum Development in Rural China
- Participant Prof. William Nitzky (California State University Chico, Department of Anthropology, United States)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- 14.30 Thai Museology and International Standards of Heritage Management
- Participant Ms. Rebecca Weldon Sithiwong (Consultant in Museology)
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper
- [WITHDRAWN] Making the Past Speak Again: Practicing Heritage across Cultural Boundaries
- Participant Prof. Zongjie Wu (Institute of Cross-cultural and Regional Studies, Zhejiang University )
- 30 minutes | 9:00 AM - 9:30 AM Part of: Heritage Shifts in East Asia: Communication between Global Policies and Local Practices
- Paper