Skip to main page content

WORKSHOP 1: Kristin Andrews- The "Other" Problems: Mind, Behavior, and Agency.

Decorative image for session WORKSHOP 1: Kristin Andrews- The "Other" Problems: Mind, Behavior, and Agency.

My Session Status

7:30 PM, Tuesday 26 Jun 2018 (2 hours)
animal mindsconsciousnessmindreading

Mind-reading, or the ability to attribute mental states to others, is a familiar and significant ability for adult humans, and the investigation into whether humans are alone in this capacity has been a vexed topic over the last forty years. There are three key complexities to the investigation: one, there are a host of different kinds of content that could be mind-read (e.g. perceptual states, emotions, beliefs); two, there are a host of different kinds of methods for coming to learn about others’ mental content (e.g. perception, cognitive attribution, mirroring plus interoception); three, we lack a good understanding of these capacities in humans, and false assumptions can lead the investigation into animal mind-reading astray. With these complexities on the table, we can turn to the recent research suggesting that great apes attribute false belief to others (Krupenye et al. 2016; Buttelmann et al. 2017). I will argue that these studies do not provide converging evidence that apes have the concept of belief or can attribute belief to others, and that likewise the infant studies that these experiments are based on fail to offer evidence of belief attribution, at least on familiar representational accounts of what a belief is. I will present an alternative function for belief attribution, namely, the explanation of anomalous behavior. I’ll discuss the extent to which other species might have this capacity, and what sorts of studies we could do in order to better investigate the question of mind-reading belief across species. I will also discuss the importance of looking at the ways different species may solve their own versions of the other minds problem.

Andrews, K., & Huss, B. (2014). Anthropomorphism, anthropectomy, and the null hypothesisBiology & Philosophy29(5), 711-729. 
Andrews, K., & Gruen, L. (2014). Empathy in other apes. 
Andrews, K., & Radenovic, L. (2008). Animal cognitionThe International Encyclopedia of Ethics.
Andrews, K., Crozier, G., Donaldson, S., Fenton, A., Johnson, L. S. M., Jones, R., ... & Rocha, J. (2018). The Philosophers' Brief on Chimpanzee Personhood.  
Domes, G., Heinrichs, M., Michel, A., Berger, C., & Herpertz, S. C. (2007). Oxytocin improves “mind-reading” in humansBiological Psychiatry61(6), 731-733.

Kristin Andrews (Speaker)
York University

Christiane Bailey 
Université de Montréal
Gordon Burghardt 
Alumni Distinguished Service Professor University of Tennessee

Stevan Harnad 
Professor UQÀM & McGill

Christiane Bailey

Other Participant

Gordon Burghardt

Other Participant

Jonathan Birch

Other Participant

My Session Status

Session detail
Allows attendees to send short textual feedback to the organizer for a session. This is only sent to the organizer and not the speakers.
To respect data privacy rules, this option only displays profiles of attendees who have chosen to share their profile information publicly.

Changes here will affect all session detail pages