Passer au contenu de la page principale

Politics of Scale: A New Approach to Heritage Studies I

Mon statut pour la session

Quoi:
Regular session
Quand:
15:30, Samedi 4 Juin 2016 (1 heure 30 minutes)
Thème:
Heritage Changes Politics
Mots-clés:
Heritage changes politicsPolitical uses of heritageUses of heritageHeritage and conflicts
In recent decades, the growth of the World Heritage industry has necessitated the reconsideration of scale. Formerly dominated by nation-states, some influential international organizations such as UNESCO and its advisory bodies (ICOMOS and IUCN) are now taking a strong role in decision-making through policy-making and implementation. Despite the power of the transnational organization and its relation with states parties, there is a growth of regionalism and “localism” in the heritage industry. The 2003 Intangible Cultural Heritage Convention has strong support from several Asian countries and, to some extent, reflects their wills and interests. Regional organizations have sprung up in South Asia, Africa and Caribbean, promoting regional heritage identities against the hegemonic value stemming from European heritage discourse. These phenomena indicate that the power structure of the heritage industry is not fixed; rather, it refers to a process of reconfiguration and contestation along different scales.
We believe the concept of “politics of scale” is crucial in critical heritage studies by tracing the “power geometries” (Massey 1996) of how heritage works. We also criticize how the European-dominant language of heritage affects local traditions, cultural practices and daily life in the form of authorized heritage discourse (Smith 2006). Although the seminal work “A Geography of Heritage” (Graham, Ashworth and Tunbridge 2000) brings the concept of “scale” to heritage studies, the concept of “politics of scale” is not yet well developed to analyze the social construction of heritage scales through socio-political contestation. Recently, David Harvey encouraged heritage studies to take the understanding of scale into account for further theorization of heritage. As he stated, “to understand how heritage works, we must examine what scale does, and how heritage and scale interact” (2015:3).
In this session we echo Harvey’s call, and seek to investigate the interrelation between the re-theorization of scale and heritage. This session will not only examine scale as a fixed unit and exiting category with certain spatial boundary such as “local, regional, national and international,” but also explore how scale works as a process of “hierarchization and re-hierarchization.” We will also deploy the pluralistic meanings of “politics of scale” (Brenner 2001) to analyze the power struggle during the process of production, reconfiguration and contestation within and among heritage scales.
With these issues in mind, we invite papers looking into the following themes:
• How scale is used by heritage institutions to legitimate their authority and produce hierarchies among scales;
• How heritage discourse is reinforced and affects other scales based on the power structure and uneven development between scales;
• How local struggles emerge to negotiate with the discourse through moving between and along scales.
We encourage papers from different approaches or disciplines, since we believe the plural form of “heritage studies” makes it a multi- inter-disciplinary area that benefits from communication, collaboration or even contestation. Each discipline is embedded in one scale or many (such as individual, local, regional, national and global), and we hope the critical interaction of these approaches will generate new insights into heritage studies.

Dr Yujie Zhu

Modérateur.rice

Sous sessions

15:30 - 16:00 | 30 minutes

As heritage research has engaged with a greater plurality of heritage practices, scale has emerged as an important concept in heritage studies, albeit relatively narrowly defined as hierarchical levels (household, local, national, etcetera). This paper will argue for a definition of scale in heritage research that incorporates size (geographical scale), level (vertical scale) and relation (an understanding that scale is constituted through dynamic relationships in specific contexts). The p...

Dr Tod Jones

Participant.e
15:30 - 16:00 | 30 minutes

In constructing the scales that frame our political, social and cultural lives, we do not neutrally siphon off a particular part of the world and label it as local, national or global. Instead, processes of scaling are concerned with the perceived relationships between physical and psychological areas of different sizes and importance. This paper will seek to examine the relationship between areas and objects valued for their cultural heritage and the spaces and populations surrounding the...

Rowena Butland

Participant.e
15:30 - 16:00 | 30 minutes

This paper will focus on the production of border heritage within the framework of European Union (EU) cross-border cooperation programs. In these borderlands, tourism development, fostered by cross-border cooperation initiatives, displays an active heritagization of the border, by enacting various visual and textual representations of the border. Tourism development and touristic heritage production may become a site of contestation over the meaning of borders. According to such an unders...

María Lois

Participant.e

Mon statut pour la session

Évaluer

Detail de session
Pour chaque session, permet aux participants d'écrire un court texte de feedback qui sera envoyé à l'organisateur. Ce texte n'est pas envoyé aux présentateurs.
Afin de respecter les règles de gestion des données privées, cette option affiche uniquement les profils des personnes qui ont accepté de partager leur profil publiquement.

Les changements ici affecteront toutes les pages de détails des sessions