Food as Heritage: Uses and Consequences of Food as an Object of Cultural Value
My Session Status
This session is committed to extending previous research collaborations on food and culinary systems as objects of political mobilization – ICA 52, 2006 (Seville); Mexico DF, 2009; ICA 54, 2012 (Vienna); Uqam, 2014 (Montreal). On this occasion, we will deepen and develop ongoing debates about the growing place of food in the cultural politics of heritage and its impacts on society, about which there is still scarce documentation.
How are food and culinary heritages constructed and how do they contribute to the consolidation of identities and economies? Its implementation shows food heritage as the result of a complex process: it combines objectives fostered by civil society and those promoted by political instances, to different degrees and for various reasons, as it engages identity, development, and markets in their relations with a diversity of food practices, produces, and crops. Within this constellation of actors and goals, food heritage can be stretched into many directions between the poles of multiple opportunities of commodification and the enhancement of the human activities that constitute it, and thus can bring both positive and negative effects on society. Against this background many questions arise:
Why should food be considered as heritage? Which are the criterion of food and culinary practices to be selected as heritage? What does food heritagization reveal about the relations between food and nation, food and region, food and community? Which approaches are suitable for studying the foundations and aims of culinary nationalisms, including the possible shifts and tensions between institutional and everyday identity politics? To what extent does food heritagization create consensus? Or, at the contrary, could it be at the center of social and economic tensions?
The session aims to foster critical reflection on the consequences and social implications of the uses of food as a resource that both shapes collective identities and supports ideologies and social claims. In other words, the transformational potential of food heritagization will be questioned.
Of particular interest is to address the relations between food heritage and local development policies, the encounter between economic requirements and opportunities (for example, through gastronomic tourism) and the safeguarding of local and “traditional” food biodiversity and practices.
Food heritage-making and innovation-through-heritagization at the local level will be as critical as the wider effects of the globalization of heritage policies and programs. The presentations will highlight the trans-regional dimensions of food heritagization and develop examinations taking into account those excluded from heritage-making processes. Similarly, the circulation, transformation, exchange, and (re-)appropriation processes of food and culinary forms, knowledge, and policies across the world will be addressed. Finally, critical and contesting initiatives relying on food heritage-making as well as studies on the role of food in contemporary identity formation will be discussed.
The very idea of this session is to show how focusing on the particularity of food heritage – tangible and intangible at the same time, and containing a broad and flexible range in which culture, identity and markets meet to varying degrees –, allows for the rethinking of cultural heritage policies and initiatives.
Sub Sessions
Depuis le milieu du dix-huitième siècle, alors que sa consommation est rapportée depuis l’Antiquité, la truffe est devenue un symbole majeur du luxe alimentaire et de la gastronomie européenne. Le « diamant de la cuisine » est un produit de distinction sociale par excellence et n’est travaillé en frais que par des restaurants haut de gamme. Au-delà de sa rareté et des mystères inhérents à sa production, la truffe et sa consommation sont entourées d’un imaginaire profondément enraciné dans ...
This comparative paper will examine how discourses and practices concerning gastronomic heritage serve as agents of sustainable change and transformation in towns from three different continents. Food has long been considered a primary marker of cultural heritage, and in many places around the world it helps foster cultural revitalization movements: bottom-up, community-based undertakings that stand in stark contrast to traditional economic development paradigms. A revitalization movement ...
Washoku (literally, “Japanese food”) is now formally designated as Intangible Heritage of Humanity under the cultural heritage inscription system of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO). In Japan, this formal inscription of washoku into the UNESCO system was considered a victory for Japanese food; the excellence if not superiority of Japanese food was seen to have been validated through official heritage status. This paper will look at how c...
C’est à travers la mémoire patrimoniale que nous analyserons la façon dont s’est produit et structuré le patrimoine alimentaire dans la France de la fin du XXe siècle et du début du XXIe siècle, notamment en passant de la sphère du tangible à celle de l’intangible. À travers des productions et des appropriations, mouvantes selon les moments de l’histoire et les besoins de la communauté, à travers l'investissement que ce patrimoine recueille et les usages auxquels il est voué, nous nous int...
En 1997, le groupe Promodès (un des principaux distributeurs français de l’époque) décide de créer une marque de terroir baptisée « Reflets de France ». Cette marque, la première de ce type, allait connaître un fort succès. Une fois le groupe Promodès racheté par Carrefour en 2000, elle allait poursuivre sa progression et devenir le leader des marques que l’on pourrait qualifier de marques patrimoniales de masse. Cette communication s’attardera sur les critères qui ont permis d’identifier,...
This paper will examine the tensions and concomitant consensus-building processes inherent in creating, performing, and ultimately marketing food-based heritage claims as a driver for positive socio-economic change in the city of Tucson, Arizona, USA by gaining international recognition under the UNESCO “Creative Cities” brand. The principal author, an archaeologist by training and head of the Historic Preservation Office in the City of Tucson, is the primary architect of a complex nominat...